Let's be real: the rental market has softened, and St. Louis isn't completely insulated from it. Nationally, rents have now declined year-over-year for 28 consecutive months, sitting about 1.5% below where they were a year ago. Vacancy rates have climbed to 7.4% — a multi-year high not seen since tracking began in 2017 — and the average rental unit is sitting on the market for 40 days before being leased. That's four days longer than a year ago, and more than double the pace during the 2021 frenzy. Renters have options right now, and they know it.
The national numbers tell a clear story: a historic wave of new apartment construction — 591,000 units delivered in 2024 alone — flooded the market faster than demand could absorb it. That pipeline is finally slowing (a projected 414,000 deliveries in 2026), but the existing inventory is still being digested. Cities like Austin, TX have seen rents drop nearly 6% year-over-year. Sun Belt markets that saw explosive growth are now offering 1-2 months of free rent just to fill units.
Here in St. Louis, we're feeling some of those same pressures at street level. The good news is that our market remains one of the most affordable in the country — and that matters. When renters in overbuilt metros get priced out or start looking for stability, the Midwest becomes increasingly attractive. St. Louis rents remain well below the national median, which keeps baseline demand steadier than in markets that overheated.
But let's not sugarcoat it: pricing competitively and presenting your property well matters more than it did two years ago. Tenants are comparison shopping. A unit that sat vacant for two weeks in 2022 might sit for six weeks today if it isn't priced right or showing well.
What does this mean for you as an owner?
First, hold your good tenants. A vacancy in this market costs more than a modest rent concession. If a reliable tenant's lease is coming up, getting ahead of the renewal conversation is one of the smartest moves you can make right now — more on that in our separate post on tenant retention.
Second, be realistic about rent increases. Small, incremental increases on strong long-term tenants often make more sense than rolling the dice on a new applicant in a softer market.
Third, lean on your property manager. This is exactly the kind of market where having someone who knows local comps, vacancy trends, and tenant behavior is worth every dollar. Data and timing matter more than ever.
The broader market is expected to stabilize gradually through 2026, with analysts forecasting a slow, steady recovery rather than any sharp rebound. For St. Louis owners, that means staying patient, staying proactive, and making smart decisions — not reactive ones.
We'll continue to track these trends each quarter. If you have questions about how the current market affects your specific property, reach out to your First Door PM contact directly.
Sources